After rereading the entire works of the great Victorian novelist during the pandemic, Peter Conrad became convinced – whisper it – that Dickens is an even greater writer than that other British literary giant, the BardWho is better, Dickens or Shakespeare? We asked nine prominent writersEarly in 2020, as society shut down, I retreated behind closed doors with Charles Dickens, who kept me company and cheered me up throughout the pandemic. Carried along by narratives that Dickens thought of as speedy locomotives and warmed by a combustible imagination that he compared to an industrial forge, I soon felt no need for tame timed circuits of the local park, and I even stopped fretting about the imminent end of the world. But although Dickens saved from me one disease, he infected me with another: escaping Covid-19, I contracted an incurable monomania instead.Emerging after the last lockdown, I buttonholed any friend who would listen and began to claim that Dickens contained the whole of l...
The article presents a compelling argument for reevaluating Charles Dickens in comparison to William Shakespeare, challenging the traditional view of Shakespeare's superiority. Peter Conrad, after immersing himself in Dickens' works during the pandemic, posits that Dickens may be as great, if not greater, than Shakespeare.
Key points include:
1. Dickens' Ambition and Style: Dickens was aware of Shakespeare's acclaim but saw himself as a versatile rival. He created detailed, idiosyncratic characters, unlike Shakespeare's more abstract figures that rely on actors for realization.
2. Social and Political Commentary: Dickens used his work to critique society and politics directly, making him a controversial yet impactful figure. His characters often served as critiques of societal issues, unlike Shakespeare's more universal themes.
3. Cultural Status: While Shakespeare is idolized for his ambiguity and universality, Dickens is seen as more accessible yet polarizing. His works are direct and specific, reflecting his time and social concerns.
4. Challenging Icons: Dickens' characters sometimes critique Shakespeare, showing his boldness in challenging literary icons. This reflects his competitive spirit and desire to stand out.
In conclusion, the article argues that Dickens deserves more credit for his versatility, character depth, and social critique, making a case for his literary greatness and sparking debate about his standing relative to Shakespeare.
